Magnepan MMG Floorstanding Speakers
Magnepan MMG Floorstanding Speakers
[Jul 21, 2006]
Darin
Audio Enthusiast
Strength:
Sheer unbelievable musicality. Huge soundstage. They look cool. Brilliant with all types of music. Fantastic resolution.
Weakness:
Kinda hard to place in a small room when you are married. I have been listening to the Maggies for about a week now. I am in a slightly different situation to many of the reviewers here, 'cos I live in Australia, where a pair of MG12's retail for $3000 AUD - roughly $2200 USD. This makes the MMG's even more of a bargain than they already are, but it also puts them up against more expensive speakers than in the US market.
|
[Jun 26, 2006]
mjc143
AudioPhile
Strength:
Moe detail than you will find in a similarly priced speaker.
Weakness:
None for the price. First day and these have proven far better than m Athena AS F2.2. My 50 Watt Antique Sound Labs Tube Amp has plenty of power to drive them. If you"ve been tempted but turned off by comments of high power requirements, touchy placement, need for expensive or DIY aftermarket stands, or other finicky requirememts, just do it. You won't be disapointed. Bass is articulate and natural. The Athenas went down to 35Hz and I don't miss it.
Customer Service Easy, Friendly, and Prompt. Shipped Same Day. Similar Products Used: Athena ASF2.2
|
[Jun 23, 2006]
Peter Elem
Audio Enthusiast
Strength:
Articulate, realistic, tramsparency, transport to the original music.
Weakness:
Limited high frequency distribution, which is an advantage in difficult rooms. I have had three maggies before this, culminating in the 2.7 QR, which frankly left me a little cold. Bigger isn't always better and I think the magnepan design lends itself to two way designs and needs refinement to get to the three way iteration (3.x series). Also I moved into a smaller room for my listening so the 2.7's dominated the room. Maggies have to breath so the speaker size should match the room. They all seem to have that "quality" and the MMG is no exception. I needed a change and the factory deal attracted me after I sold the 2.7's, especially since I live in a high sales tax area!
|
[May 19, 2006]
Richard Schneider
AudioPhile
Strength:
Sound that draws you in, easy to listen to, unfatiguing, natural.
Weakness:
Speaker connection fussy and quaint. Why not banana inputs? C'mon. On the other hand, it will accept banana plugs, and being light, you can turn 'em upside down to make the connections from a comfortable standing position rather than a cramped crouching one. I had been considering entry-level Maggies since they introduced the SMG, but had declined in the belief that my listening space would be a limiting factor in setting them up. My most recent speaker pair had been the Radio Shack Optimus, like the Maggies, a steal for the price, and interestingly enough, they employed an approach to ribbon technology in their tweeters. I swore not to replace them unless they could be improved upon at a somewhat reasonable price. But build quality and durability proved their undoing. I still have a working pair in the rear channel, but the Optimus is no longer made.
|
[May 12, 2006]
popetucson
Audio Enthusiast
Strength:
Imaging, tonal quality, looks, build quality, MADE IN THE U.S.A
Weakness:
Really need to focus on placement and a good EQ system is very beneficial. Well, I am listening to these speakers as I write this review, and the sound is truly amazing for $550.00. I have heard $2000.00 speakers that do not even come close to this sound. I have these hooked to a Hafler DH500 amp that puts out 400 watts RMS per channel into 4 ohms, and that is running off of a Pioneer Elite receiver as the pre-amp, I am using the Pioneer because of its EQ capabilities, it has a 5 band EQ for each channel, and this really helps since these speakers are very sensitive to how and where they are placed. I am a rocker, and I find that these speakers do just fine for this type of music, the only problem you will have with these speakers is the quality of the recording you are listening to regardless of type of music. I have these speakers paired with a good subwoofer crossed over at 50hz, this seems to integrate very well. I had just purchased a pair of Infinity Beta 50 speakers a couple of weeks before I ran across these, there is no comparison, the mmgs are in a different catagory, these speakers are at the begining of the audiophile food chain. In closing ,all that I can say is try them for yourself,remeber you will have 60 days to send them back, but I could not even imagine that unless your room or electronics just did not work with them. And by the way, the Infinities are setting in the closet waiting to go on ebay. Happy listening. Similar Products Used: INFINITY, POLK, ACOUSTIC RESEARCH, WHARFDALE , ECT |
[Jan 20, 2006]
Tinear
AudioPhile
Strength:
MMGs (with after market stands) are BEST is small rooms with subs. Even betters the 1.6s dynamically and in imaging. For larger rooms (BIG) go to the 1.6s, 3.6s or 20.1s but use better stands on all of them. The smaller the Maggie the better. (But Magnepan doesn't make money that way.)
Weakness:
Maggies tend to sound better if you bring them out into the room focused toward YOU. All Maggies are room sensitive. Don't think the larger Maggie will be better in a smaller room. It won't happen. Know what YOUR limitations are! I'm hesitant about writing a review here for lots of reasons but here goes. If you are contemplating buying an HT/MUSIC system you would be wise to compare speakers from Axiom (the Axiom 80tis)(or any derevitives) versus the Magnepan (MMGs)(or any derivatives). Both are available on the internet in (comparatively) inexpensive packages with 30 to 60 days return priveleges). With these two magnificent speakers systems you will HEAR the difference between dynamic and planar presentations of sound in order to make up YOUR mind as to YOUR preference. These two speakers systems (to my ears) represent the best value commercially of what are "THE BEST BUYS" in speaker audio. If they don't sound good on your system then YOUR electronics and YOUR room are at fault. The bottom line here is you don't have to spend a bundle of money to get EMOTIONALLY SATISFYING sound. No matter what all the other Audioholic critics say. But there is one caveat with the MMGs and all Magnepan speakers (get rid of the stock stands!) MMGs sound SO much better with other stands than with the stock ones.(Sometimes I feel as if Magnepan does not want you to know just how good the MMGs are inorder to sell you the more expensive ones. Try the Mye or Sound Anchor stands.) Either of these speaker systems are phenomenal and sure to satisfy all those except the unsatisfiable. Similar Products Used: This review is my gift after over 50 years of experimentation. |
[Dec 16, 2005]
themystic3000
Audio Enthusiast
Strength:
Big soundstage, excellent instrument resolution, natural sound reproduction.
Weakness:
I haven't found any yet. Hi all, I have loved Magneplanars since I was a teenager, and now that I am a 40-year-old adult with good job, an CD habit and a set of blown RTRs, I figured it was time to upgrade to a set of Magneplanars. I looked at the more expensive Maggies at a local dealership in Woodland Hills but ultimately decided to "try out" the MMGs, since I could trade them in for credit for more expensive models later if I so desired, and since I do have a relatively small listening room. I listen almost exclusively to electronica, so I was curious to hear how the MMGs would handle oddly shaped synthetic sound waves and detailed instrument positioning and stereo effects. I feel I got more than my money's worth out of the MMGs with my listening tastes. I have a listening room in my two-bedroom apt. in lovely Thousand Oaks that's about 10' x 12', so the MMGs were a good choice. Their soundstage fills the room completely--no weird positioning needed--no touchy sweet spot. Conjure One female vocalists sound breathy and sensual. Electronic soundwaves come across clean. Delerium aural textures are easily distinguished from one another. The MMGs deliver Kraftwerk baroque layers with purity. Uberzone's quasi-instruments are positioned as if space was an absolute. I have a trusty Yamaha R-V98 that's about 10 years old that sounds great with the MMGs. I have yet to try it with the DSP effects. I don't know if I will. I put the satellite speakers up for sale--I love the MMGs' clarity and purity so much I think the DSP effects of the Yamaha are irrelevant now to my listening pleasure. Similar Products Used: Martin Logan (yuch) |
[Nov 29, 2005]
mhardman2005
Audio Enthusiast
Strength:
Clear, transparent, acoustic and vocals sound amazingly lifelike
Weakness:
Limited volume, limited bass and treble extension A bargain introduction to the Maggie sound, more than enough to have you hooked for a lifetime! You'll never go back to boxes. Compared to similarly priced boxy speakers they're clear, transparent, lifelike and totally addicting. Only caveat is I made the mistake of thinking the 1.6s are more or less the same thing so should sounds very similar. No, the 1.6s sound even better - all the MMG strengths are there but much more! If you can, go the extra mile and get the 1.6s. |
[Nov 20, 2005]
Yen
Audio Enthusiast
Strength:
Great fidelity for female vocals (Diana Krall) and the clasic combo. All wood instruments sound remarkable. Gives new life to solid-state amps and digital music by adding texture.
Weakness:
Difficult placement since they need a lot of space to breath. Narrow sweet spot. Light on the bass frequencies. Power hungry. Forget about using 6 watt SET amps, you'll need a 60 watt push-pull or 80 watt solid state and boast the bass. If you're a high school or college student and like to PARTY...then these are NOT for you. But...if you like to do some critical listening at moderate levels, then you must add these speakers to your collection. There are some things these speakers simply can't do...but it can do other things exceptionally well...well enough to astonish you when listening to old CDs that had previously grown tiresome. These MMGs are worth the experience. |
[Nov 13, 2005]
Coop33
Audio Enthusiast
Strength:
Tweeter and midrange are the best I've ever heard. Quality construction and delivery. Very large soundstage.
Weakness:
None with the speakers (I would redesign the stands though for 'lifting' capability). Well, I finally got my Maggies. I had been researching speakers and receivers for some time, and finally decided to go with the HK 3480 driving a pair of MMG's. First off, packaging was excellent from Magnepan, and setup of the factory stands is very simple...literally four screws on each speaker. As you have no doubt heard, these speakers are very directional with a very clear sweet spot that's impossible to miss. Moving horizontally in front of the speakers is MUCH more forgiving that vertical dispersion, meaning that sitting anywhere on a couch would be fine if you are facing the speakers within their width, but standing up does take a lot of that Maggie magic away. After much testing of different scenarios, I found that placing the MMG's in almost an equalateral triangle with the center of the listening position worked the best, with the tweeter portion of the speakers facing in as Magnepan recommends. I tried them both ways, but I felt 'tweeters in' produced a more consise and accurate soundstage. These speakers are not best suited to be on the floor. I found that the best sound occured when the speakers were straight up and lifted about 2 feet off of the ground...this immerses you in sweet spot while seated and drastically reduces losing sound quality while standing. And boy oh boy is that sweet spot sweet. The midrange and tweeter sections are mind boggling...I am listening to my whole collection again and can hear things I never could before. Percussion, acoustics, piano, and vocals come to life with a 'being there live' sincerity. The soundstage is very large. A particular song that I was listening to starts out with clapping that was concentrated to one side of the recording area...the speakers are set up in my place so that that side faces my front door. Everytime the song comes on, my dog goes to the door and starts barking like there are people outside. The imaging is fantastic. The bass has come along nicely in only the first week of use. Out of the box, the MMG's are a bit bright and the bass really isn't there...but after a bit of break-in, the bass becomes adequate for most music types and the brightness falls off. To sum this up, I don't beleive there is a better deal out there right now. I am actually in shock at the level of quality and value that I received for the money. I highly recommend these speakers to anyone who wants more from their music. Similar Products Used: Polk, Infinity, B&W. |