Roksan Caspian CD Players

Roksan Caspian CD Players 

DESCRIPTION

cd transport/dac combo

USER REVIEWS

Showing 11-20 of 24  
[Nov 22, 2000]
Neil Crowley
Audio Enthusiast

Strength:

Heavy, build quality, styling, musicality

Weakness:

Very sensitive-can skip

This unit is replacing an older EAD CD-1000. When I first hooked it up the sound was different but at first listen I couldn't tell right away if it was better. After A-B'ing the 2 players and settling in for some extended listening I gained some insight into the difference I was hearing. At first there seemed to be more detail from the EAD, as it had a brighter presentation of high frequencies. The Roksan, on the other hand, had a more relaxed top end but sounded truer to the music. I realized there were artifacts showing up from the EAD that produced a sheen to the music. With no comparison it just sounded like more detail than the Roksan. The Roksan, however, actually has more detail but without the top end glare. So much kinder on the ears and conducive to longer listening.

My wife got control of the Roksan and wouldn't give it back. She said it was good to go through her music collection and listen again with the improved sound.

Both CD players were initially played through a Creek 4330R. I did enjoy the Caspian CD palyer so much that I bought the Caspian integrated amplifier as well. What a pair! The music presentation is so pleasant and non-fatiguing that I have been spending lots of time planted in the sweet-spot listening to music. Very musical indeed!

This is a heavy unit. The materials and build quality are exemplary. And it's stylish. I have always had "black box" components and thought nothing of it. The Roksan Caspian series looks great and enhances the decor of the room. I didn't think the aesthetics of the equipment was important but I do enjoy having a great looking stereo. Definetely a factor in spouse acceptance.

I like the soft green glow of the display, especially with the lights low or off. I perceive it as more artsy & soothing rather than being the ultimate hi-tech statement. I prefer this to a big, busy display that lasers into my eyes when I'm trying to relax with the lights dim or off. My opinion for what it's worth.

On the down side, my player is critical of scratched or dirty discs-they will skip. The first time it happened I thought the player was broken and called the shop where I bought it(www.generubinaudio.com Gene Rubin is a great guy to do business with). Gene suggested cleaning the unit before considering repair as he has experience with other CD players doing the same thing when in need of cleaning. I cleaned the CD and skipping stopped. Hasn't really been a problem. Skips once every 2-3 weeks. I just clean the CD, or if it's scratched, replay that section. I think, from what I've heard, that this may be specific to my individual player. I had to write that up but it's so infrequent as to be a non-event.

In summary, the CD player is a pleasure to own and use. It's all there: Truth & correctness in timber, tone, texture & detail. Soundstage has some real dimension, non-fatiguing sound & musicality! I'm happy with my purchase and would line up to buy it again.

Similar Products Used:

EAD CD-1000

OVERALL
RATING
5
VALUE
RATING
5
[Oct 07, 2000]
menachem toren
Audio Enthusiast

Strength:

quality, sound, soundstage, reputation

Weakness:

display

I AM VERY HAPPY WITH THIS CD PLAYER
USED WITH THE ROKSAN AMP AND THEY WORK VERY WELL TOGETHER
VERY GOOD VALUE FOR THE MONEY I PAID!

OVERALL
RATING
5
VALUE
RATING
5
[Jul 30, 2000]
Galen Valentine
Audiophile

Strength:

Soundstage and imaging

Weakness:

Can occasionally hear the CD spinning

Let me first say, any review of electronic equipment should be taken with a certain amount of skepticism. Components that sound outstanding in my system may not in yours. Having said that, I'm including a list of associated equipment at the end of this review. Reviews are helpful in narrowing a large list of choices.

I probably should have waited to write this review since I've only had the unit two weeks. But the improvement over my previous digital front-end is too marvelous to remain silent. The Roksan Caspian replaced an MSB Link DAC/McCormack CD Drive transport combination. While the MSB is one the best values in DACs it was no competition for the Roksan in my system. Having listened to the MSB for over a year I must disagree with the reviewer who felt the Roksan sounded like the MSB with a cheap Harmon changer. One thing that always bothered me was its lack of depth. The Roksan worked wonders in this area. But, not alone. I upgraded the power cord to a Marigo Audio Labs Resolution. It still isn't the ultimate in depth; but then I doubt I could afford it even if it existed. Instruments (especially strings and piano) sound more natural than with the MSB. Occasionally the extreme highs e.g. the triangle, sound, not bright, but a little forward. Classical music is my primary focus but I also listen to pop, rock, some jazz, world music, and new age. It is difficult to build a system capable of playing all of these genres with equal aplomb at any price let alone one that is affordable. I believe the Roksan a good component in this regard. Over the past two weeks it has played everything I threw at it with control and musicality. At no time did I feel that I made a wrong choice. In fact, I kept listening to the music rather than the sound. Entire CDs would finish when I had intended to critically listen to only one track.

Any criticisms? Well, yes. I am annoyed with the cheap looking display. You would think that a $1700 CD Player would have a better looking display. Every once in a while I can hear the CD spinning. I also wish it had HDCD decoding. Am I nitpicking? Probably.

Associate Equipment:

Roksan Caspian CD Player
Sony S300 DVD Player
Technics SHAC300 Dolby Digital Processor
Rotel RSP980 A/V Preamp
B&K Components AV6000II Power Amp
Paradigm Reference Studio 60 Loudspeakers
Hsu Research VTF-2 Active Subwoofer
Signet SLC50 Center Channel
Atlantic Research Surrounds
Custom bi-wire speaker cable
Kimber 4PR speaker cable
Stealth Silver interconnects
Custom interconnects
AudioQuest Topaz interconnects
Stealth HAC power cord
AudioQuest power cord
Marigo Audio Labs Resolution power cord
Sonic Horizon Hurricane Power Strip
Michael Green Designs Five-Shelf Justarack
various homebrew tweaks

It is always difficult to give numeric ratings. I give it a four value rating because competition is fierce in the $1200 - $2000 price range e.g. Musical Fidelity X-Ray. Overall rating, again I give it a four. With the Marigo Audio Labs Resolution and a Sonic Horizons Hurricane power strip helping out its overall rating, in my system, is a five.

Similar Products Used:

Sony DVD Player, MSB Link/McCormack Transport Combo, Sony multi-disc

OVERALL
RATING
4
VALUE
RATING
4
[Mar 21, 2000]
Sivalingam Rameish
Audio Enthusiast

Strength:

Heavy, retro styling, looks well built

Weakness:

Harsh sound, tracking problems

Harsh sound. Very unmusical. There are certainly far better players out there that will better the Roksan Caspian. Quality contol is suspect as 2 units were found faulty. Buyers beware. The 2 years warranty as stated in the brochure doesn't apply to all markets. Roksan itself will honour it but the hassle and cost of shipping something this heavy is costly.

Similar Products Used:

Copland 289, Rotel 855

OVERALL
RATING
1
VALUE
RATING
1
[Feb 22, 2001]
Viraj Theberis
Audio Enthusiast

Strength:

Natural (ie. not digital) sound, clarity and vibrance suited to classical, acoustics styles just as well as rock. Superb with modern music styles, forgiving on bad redoring. Build quality.Looks.

Weakness:

No HDCD, 24bit resolution, lack of certain useful features (e.g. random play) but bear in mind this is being fairly picky

This is an 'entry level into the hi-end' CD player from a repsected British maker of hi-end vinyl turntables. As expected, great care and attention has been paid to build quality and solidity, this is a quality product weighing in at roughly 25pounds!

This is due to the separate porwer supplies to the dac and drive mechanism and the 5 separate ciruit boards to minimise interference from each other.

The sound is more akin to a top flight turntable than to digital with Roksans special green dye in the laser claimed to smooth glare and harshness from the sound. I acn see what Roksan mean after hearing other respected players from Meridian and Cyrus amongst others.

Roksan continually update the inner working of the Caspian CD player although to date no 24bit or HDCD/SACD/DVD-A compatibility is availible, THIS PLAYER JUST GETS ON WITH THE JOB OF PLAYING GREAT SOUNDING FATIGUE FREE MUSIC, RELIABLY, DAY IN/DAY OUT.

Not a flash 'lookatme' kinda player, more of a quiet wolf in stylish rather than fashionable clothes - the Caspian is a great investment and will provide years of hassle free, musical enjoyment - DEFINITLEY PUT IT DOWN ON YOUR LIST TO AUDITION IF YOU ARE IN THE MARKET FOR A HIGH QUALITY DIGITAL FRONT END FOR YOUR SYSTEM - Considering its price (i think $1400 in the U.S.?) it mixes well in the illustrious company of my Shainians ($2000) and Musical Fidelity Nuvista ($4500) amp - THAT ITSELF IS A TESTAMENT TO THIS PLAYERS QUALITY.

Similar Products Used:

Marantz, Sony,CD players,Kenwood & Sony Minidisk Player/Recorders

OVERALL
RATING
5
VALUE
RATING
4
[Sep 11, 1999]
Rob Dyte
an Audiophile

I have just gone through the process of upgrading my CD front end. This turned out to be a very long process. I first took home a Naim CD3, the sound was very upfront and harsh. You could not listen to this player for too longer period. Next, i took home a Primare D20 CD player, the complete opposite to the NAIM CD3. This player was very uninspiring to say the least. After thinking all CD players were lousy up stepped the Roksan Capsian. What can i say, this is the best CD player i have ever heard. The control, detail and general soundstage of this player is exceptional. I can hardly believe the difference. This has to be a veritable bargain at £895.

OVERALL
RATING
5
VALUE
RATING
[Dec 01, 2001]
Tony Whitfield
Audio Enthusiast

Strength:

Lovely open sound with bags of detail and air.

Weakness:

Drawer mechanism could be better.

The Caspian has a lovely open sound and no harshness whatsoever. I previously owned the Marantz CD17 Mk2 which was much more upfront and brash. The Caspian is an altogether warmer, cleaner sound. Build quality is excellent, apart from the drawer which seems a bit fragile. Recommended for those who like lots of vocal prescence.

Similar Products Used:

Marantz CD17 MK2.

OVERALL
RATING
5
VALUE
RATING
5
[Dec 18, 1999]
Veda
Audio Enthusiast

Strength:

Forward, open, transparent

Weakness:

A bit harsh

Sounds similar to the MSB Link DAC + cheap Harman changer. Good sound but overpriced. Used with the Caspian integrated and Acustik-Lab Melody Triple.

Similar Products Used:

many

OVERALL
RATING
4
VALUE
RATING
2
[Mar 05, 2001]
High End Friend
Audiophile

Strength:

Clear and transparent sound

Weakness:

Remote controll looks ugly ;-) (compared to the Roksan Kandy modell one)

Yes, I did it. I upgraded my Roksan Kandy CD to a Roksan Caspian. I was happy with the Kandy, but now I´m very happy with the Caspian. The sound is much more clear and transparent. It is brilliant. Also the manufacturing seems to be very good, a strong cover and a good mechanic. I use it with Spendor 2/3 speakers and an Oktave VA 50 tubeamp. Speakercables are from Tara. The upgrade was the money really worth. I tried a lot of other CD´s but no one compared with the Caspian (in my configuration) at the moment. I you like a really true sound, its the player of your choice.

PS: I agree with some here said that the display could be better. But it is only the display...

OVERALL
RATING
5
VALUE
RATING
5
[Apr 25, 1999]
Gord Mitchell
an Audio Enthusiast

Cd players have come a long way since they were first introduced. You can now get detail and performance from Cd players in this price range whereas only a few yars ago you had to pay 5-10 times as much. This CD player is a great example of what technology can do over time. This player replaced a Esoteric player which only a few years ago was the king of players and only a select few could own. Now a number of us with a little less to spend can enjoy the best that a CD has to offer. Just in time for the format to change to 24/96.
Oh well, we can enjoy this Cd player. I descibe the soundstaging as layered. this is the best way to describe the layers of details and soundstaging. This soundstage is very deep and wide. The detail, yes the detail is quite unbelievable. You are there. It can handle very intense and agressive passages with ease. This CD doesn't break up when the going gets tough. It just plays what is there. Voices are sweet and timbres are excellent.
If you are looking to upgrade your front end- have a listen. This is an excellent product. Built like the proverbial and plays like it. After going through 6 other trnasports/ dacs, believe me you will be impressed! Own it and enjoy.

OVERALL
RATING
5
VALUE
RATING
Showing 11-20 of 24  

(C) Copyright 1996-2018. All Rights Reserved.

audioreview.com and the ConsumerReview Network are business units of Invenda Corporation

Other Web Sites in the ConsumerReview Network:

mtbr.com | roadbikereview.com | carreview.com | photographyreview.com | audioreview.com