Simaudio Moon i-5 Integrated Amplifiers
Simaudio Moon i-5 Integrated Amplifiers
USER REVIEWS
[Feb 26, 1999]
Aki
an Audio Enthusiast
Simply an "excellent product". I have not yet heard any better product at this price level. Better said, this is one of the best int.amp at any price level. Superb detail, soundstage and stage depth. Imaging is quite precise and smooth as a frozen yorgurt. This amplifier works best after brocken in (obviously), and warmed up without power interruption for 3days. This is not difficult as this unit is left on all the time with stand-by mode. For me, after brocken in and approx. 2days of warm-up I can notice a considerable difference. It started to sound slightly warm more like tube units. Each and every instrument grows and started sound even smoother. For those of you don't believe in cables, it's a night and day with better cables. As poor quality cable will be a bottle neck with such an excellent product as I-5. I use DHLabs through out (another excellent value manufacture). I have compared I-5 to Bryston B-60, Classe CAP-80, and Sim Audio Celeste PW-5000. Although B-60 is an excellent product, it didn't come close to Moon I-5. Classe CAP-80 was quite good but lacked smoothness and bottom end detail. PW-5000 another good product but compared to I-5, treble was slightly grainy and bottm end lacking in detail and richness. Don't take my word for it though, have a listen yourself. For those of you who live in Canada, this is the bargain of this millenium. |
[Oct 03, 1999]
Bruce Abar
an Audio Enthusiast
This Canadian made ampt is top of the line. Len has given me one to use with me C-8's speakers, boy you sure can hear the difference between the Yamaha 995 and this Amp. I will be taking emails on this ampt, if anyone would like one, just email me. With the US exchange rate, you can't beat the price. Shipping this Canadian made product Duty free is no problem. |
[Aug 18, 2000]
Eric
Audio Enthusiast
Strength:
Exceptional clarity and dynamic range; natural sound; quality remote; nice looking (new black model); 10-year warranty
Weakness:
no phono stage (external is option), or headphone jack; user manual a bit light on detail This is an outstanding integrated amp. Drives my Energy C-6s effortlessly and brings out the best in my CD player (Marantz CD-67SE). The onboard volume control is very smooth and allows excellent fine-tuning of volume level. Ditto for the remote, which adds balance control by permitting adjustment of left- and right-channel volume levels. I really like and use this feature for fine-tuning balance levels. Similar Products Used: Yamaha RX770 receiver |
[Oct 22, 1999]
Jeff
Audio Enthusiast
Strength:
Smooooooth high frequencies married to a (virtually) tube-like midrange and solid bass.
Weakness:
at 70 watts per channel, there are MUCH more powerful integrateds in the same price range ... but it is not about quantity, its about quality This is my first experience (at home) with a solidstate integrated and I have been more than pleased. The Sim is VERY well built with sound quality to match. I auditioned several other integrateds (Krell KAV 300i, Plinius 8150, Classe CAP 150) and preferred the Sim to them all. It had the right synergy with my system - Naim CD3, Vienna Acoustics Mozarts- and listening tastes. |
[Oct 30, 1999]
Bill
Audiophile
Strength:
Very musical & captivating
Weakness:
Starts to sound hard & grainy if pushed due I suspect to it's modest 70wps rating Absolutely fabulous amp for low to moderate listening levels,efficient speakers needed like the Paradigm Studio 100 V.2 that I am currently using.I hear the I-5 sounds fantastic with the JMlabs Electra 905,probably my next speaker as Paradigms are not up to the quality that this amp offers |
[Oct 24, 2000]
Paul Basinski
Audio Enthusiast
Strength:
Numerous, see below
Weakness:
Few, read on I'm on an integrated jag lately. Like the idea behind the simplicity, space saving, cost factor, and also coz integrates are no longer an audio afterthought but certified audiophile equipment. Loved the Puccini. Fat sound, very tubelike, but lacked drive, pace and bass. Went with the I-5 last summer. Extremely impressive. Super build quality, pre-outs, finally redesigned the huge remote and scaled it down; sophisticated optical volume control, etc. You get a lot for the retail of $2,600. (Though you could get good seps for that cash). The sound. Neutral on the whole. If it's on the disc this amp will pass it to your speakers like the proverbial crap through a goose. Bad CDs will sound thin and bad. If you want something to warm up the sound, this is not it. But with improved CD sound and SACD, etc, releasing more titles daily, this should not be a huge issue. The amp is punchy, fast, dynamic. The music is right there, vivid, invested with life and light. Play classical and beware when you have wide dynamic swings; the I5 will get you hoppin' out of your chair. The bass is about as tight as I've heard; it is taut, fast, not flabby at all. Amazing bass really for 70watts into 8. I haven't been able to clip the Sim, and have had music cookin' up to 104db, maxing out my ears. Mids are not as full as tubes, but I think they're very honest, no sugar coating like you get with some amps. This will appeal to some not others; I thought the Puccini was more EMOTIONAL, though with the right source the Sim can give you a real tight connection with the music. I think the highs are fine, very localizable in the soundstage, which some people dig. Major drawbacks of the I5? None really. I wouldn't match it with a bright source or tizzy speakers. If your sys leans toward dark or neutral this could be pig heaven. 10 year warranty, and the Sim guys are funny and friendly with their Quebequois Aglais! Enjoy! Similar Products Used: Audio Analogue, Puccini; Jolida 302a; Rega Mira, etc. |
[Dec 12, 1999]
A. Hebert
Audio Enthusiast
Strength:
Exceptional build quality and superb look. Very neutral and detailed sounding. Powerfull enough to drive virtually any speaker.
Weakness:
As good as it is, it still a lot of money !!! Wow, what a great integrated amp ! This is my first good Similar Products Used: None |
[Dec 10, 1999]
Michael
Audiophile
Strength:
Exceptionnal build for both amp AND remote. Beautifull sounds.
Weakness:
I wish the volume would reset to zero upon switching off to standby mode. But it's academic when compared to all the qualities. I have been listening to the I-5 for less than one month.It is simply a magical product, combining beautiful design, robust construction, and above all, beautifull sonics. Upon first listening, I started doing what most of us audiophiles do, analyzing the sound,and looking for shortcomings and flaws: high end frequencies, low end, soundstage, forward, backward, you know the routine.(If you dont you are not missing much. And I did find some flaws at first. Only to realize that these "flaws" were mainly differences between this amp and my previous one, which after all was really not all that good. We do get accustomed to the sounds of amps we own for years. In a way, it becomes our "reference" as bad or as good as it is in reality. My first listening of the I-5 was ordinary, even somewhat disapointing. Similar Products Used: Classe cap-151, Krell 300i, YBA integre, Naim separates. |
[May 09, 2000]
Brian
Audiophile
Strength:
Musical, easy to use, great value per dollar spent.
Weakness:
Not the last word in power for low impedance loads. Compared to similar products in the same price range, the SimAudio Moon I-5 offers a lot. Those considering purchasing an integrated amp do so for various reasons with space and cost considerations usually at the top of the list. The above manufacturers all produce good products, but SimAudio has the edge. The I-5 sounds most near to SimAudio separates than do any of the competing integrated amps and their respective separates. The "trickle down" effect into the I-5 is readily apparent in both sound and workmanship. Similar Products Used: Classe, Krell, and Bryston integrated amps. |