|
Review 2 of 3 Summary: This hdtv has a clear picture via the 480p inputs from a progressive scan DVD player. However, this is where the good news ends. I've had this set for over a month and have compiled this list of problems that I've experienced with this hdtv: * 480i video noise (Gary Merson's etown review of this set mentioned this as possibly an isolated incident. It is not. And no Philips rep I spoke with is willing to guarantee a fix to this problem.) * The rear-mounted fans are distractingly loud. Dramatic audio dynamics such as the opening silent space sequence of the film Contact is ruined by fan noise. You must build this set into a sound deadened wall in order to kill the fan hum. * Distortion of image with 2.40:1 anamorphic DVDs at right and left edge of screen using 480i. 480p shows the distortion more gradually but still painfully distracting. * Green convergence "plus signs" are off-center. You can adjust the Red and Blue to match the Green, but the overall convergence pattern is skewed to the right. * Convergence problems in the corners of the screen when using the either HD inputs (VGA or HVRGB). The convergence menus don't allow for adjustments near the screen corners nor along the entire top edge of the screen. * Pixel chopping on all 4 edges. Over 20 pixels of lost image data per edge. I used the Avia Home Theater Test DVD to make this measurement. * 4:3 burn-in reduction movement is not centered. It spends most of its time at the right edge of the screen. * Certain types of video input (i.e. Video Games or a VCR's Record Program Setup screen, for example) "bounces" to the point of nausea. Observed with PlayStation, N64, and Hi-Fi JVC VCR. Video games are not playable on this set. * Furthermore, I am having a hard time getting any Philips warranty centers to look at the set, let alone fix the problems I've described. Summary: This set is best used to watch 1.78:1 DVDs through the 480p component inputs. The problems described above are least noticeable in this case. Otherwise, I believe this set to be well-suited for the affluent guinea pig. Sincerely, Eric Schmidt
Strengths: Pronto Remote. Component 480p inputs. Weaknesses: Plenty. Please see Review Summary.
|