|
Review 5 of 9
Price Paid:
$2200.00
from Sumiko Audio Summary: The Electa's are without doubt one of SF's greatest failures in recent years.
I had very high hopes of these speakers based on a positive experience with Fabers, and was actually quite pleased with the way they sounded in the showroom.
However, it only took me a few days to realize their terrible shortcomings.
It starts with a midrange that seems to impress you at first, but becomes extremely irritating after a while.
The lows are out of focus, no matter where I placed the speakers, but it becomes worse as they become closer to the walls. The highs are too bright and very unnatural at times.
I did like the stage these speakers set in front of you, which seems to be very balanced and accurate. Using these speakers for home theatre actually hides their weaknesses and provides you with an excellent experience.
But again, for critical listening of high quality material, it is very evident that these speakers are certainly two or three levels lower than what they promise to be.
Don't be fooled like me and trust the name and a few hours of random listening.
Listen to them with the music you know best and make sure you are able to withstand that terribly undefined bass and that over-emphasized howling midrange.
The design is surely beautiful and at least I am at least happy about their build quality, but as soon as I can afford it I won't hesitate to get rid of them and buy something better (and maybe even cheaper).
Just to get an idea, I use a Meridian 502/557 (pre/power combo), which should be more than enough to provide these speakers with anything they're up to. Strengths: Classic Faber design, balanced sound stage, enjoyable for HT Weaknesses: Undefined bass, very bright, terrible coloring of the midrage, so-so dynamics, unnatural sound, sounds bad with any amp I tried.
|