Dr R Rankin

Overall Rating
 3 of 5

Value Rating
 4 of 5

Used product for
Less than 1 month

Visitors rate this review
3.29 of 5, 7.00 votes

Price Paid:  $0.00

Summary:
This short review is not intended to unduly cirtisize this speaker. In fact I think it is a great speaker, but it adds a certain character to the music which i dislike, but others might like a lot. So, the purpose here is to direct potential buyers towards buying this, or steering clear if their taste differs from what is offered here.

I had a good listen at a dealer to these speakers (just a casual session, I am not in the market for speakers, being very thrilled with my B&W 802d's.) What immediately striked me is the forward midbass. No matter what I tried ito setup and room position, it stayed like this. I didn't like it, one tends to start following the midbass lines instead of enjoying music.

However, that is my taste. For those looking for a high quality, good looking speaker that 'impresses' with good dynamics, this is one for your shortlist. I only listened to it in stereo, but I get the impression that for the money this will be one the very best home theatre front speaker sets.

So, if your taste in musical reproduction is purely to have musicality, donl\'t go this route. If your taste dictates having a very dynamic speaker with lots of rhythmic drive, this is the speaker for you.

Strengths:
Rhythmic drive ability

Weaknesses:
Midbass too forward
Vocals not 'there' in the soundstage (This could have been partnering equipment used in the test)

ournewceleb

Overall Rating
 5 of 5

Value Rating
 5 of 5

Used product for
1 to 3 months

Visitors rate this review
5.00 of 5, 1.00 votes

Price Paid:  $4500.00 from definitive audio

Summary:
I recently decided to upgrade from my old Studio Reference 60s to these. These speakers were selected based on listening around a variety of speakers, including more expensive ones. I am absolutely thrilled with the performance of the S8s. From top to bottom, the level of tranparency is incredible, and sounstaging is massive. For classical recordings, particularly string instruments, it sounds like the instrument is right there in front of you. I find myself listening to all of my recordings all over again, amazed at what I apparently missed before. I highly recommend, indeed urge, anyone considering spending in this price range or beyond check these out. Bring CDs with a variety of music, from rock to classic. I few (minor) negatives to mention are these suckers are quite large and heavy, and I found the sound a bit more open when they were placed from the wall a bit. They tend to dominate the living room, but heck it is worth it!

Strengths:
Realism and transparency in spades Great top and bottom Spacious soundstaging

Weaknesses:
Large and heavy, try moving around for optimium performance, e.g., not up against a wall

Similar Products Used:
Previously owned Studo ref 60. Also auditioned a host of others: studio 100s, Sonus Farber, Wilson, Martin Login, Dali, etc...

petenoak

Overall Rating
 4 of 5

Value Rating
 3 of 5

Used product for
Less than 1 month

Visitors rate this review
5.00 of 5, 3.00 votes

Price Paid:  $5400.00 from Music Lovers Audio,

Summary:
Big, rich, smooth sound. Somewhat more distant perspective. Great dynamic range. Firstly, I use a "tube-like" solid state amp with these speakers. Also, I find the speakers can be placed fairly far apart for a very spacious effect. To my ear, Classical music is just gorgeous with these speakers. That is my primary listening. I prefer these to Paradigm's Studio 100's. High strings (depending on your home acoustics) are smooth and beautiful. With some speakers (Thiel) the sound is closer, clearer, but with perhaps less atmosphere than these S8's. In Jazz or Rock, some might prefer a closer perspective, and more "edge" on the high end but for this listener the S8's work equally well for all genres. In fact, the bass end is pretty darn impressive! The string bass on Terence Blanchard's version of "Footprints" is really something: deep and true without being bloated. I don't use these for home theatre, but I wonder who would feel the need to add a subwoofer to the S8's? They certainly reproduce well below the 41 HZ in the specifications. Another aspect of these speakers is the shear size of the things. For me, taller is better! If you have space for them (they are about as large as I would consider for a living room) these speakers give the impression that sound comes from different heights including above your ear level (when seated). In Jazz, the ride cymbal comes from just where you'd expect, etc. For Bach organ music, well, you are right there in the church experiencing it's great acoustics. To be honest, these speakers may not be to everyone's taste. Perhaps at this price level, once speakers have all the size and bass you could want, you begin to choose a "sound" that you enjoy. I choose these because they sound so impressive on today's high quality recordings but also make all my old recordings, from Caruso to Ellington to Cream(!) sound good again.

Strengths:
Great bass extension. A "big" sound. Large dynamic range. Incredibly smooth top end. Tall speakers. Handsome without being pretentious. Fine wood finishes.

Weaknesses:
Some might prefer more "tingle" in top end and a closer perspective. Speakers tend towards "glow" rather than up-front clarity. Weigh over 90 lbs!

Similar Products Used:
Paradigm Studio 100, Sonus-Faber Cremona ($8K!), Thiel 2.4, Vienna Acoustics, B&W.