|
Review 4 of 4 Summary: It took me a while to set these speakers up and I felt that they need some time to break-in (about 100 hours), but once in place, they are glorious. They are detailed without being harsh and dry, they reproduce voices, strings, and piano with stunning realism, including the piano's lower octave. Soundstage is wonderful; it compared very favorably with the amazing depth reproduced by the Proac Response 4; the Cantata's reproduction of depth is by far better than the depth of the Response 3.5. Width is striking: on some recordings the soundstage stretches outside of the speakers.
I like to listen to each speaker separately just to see how it does by itself, and each Cantata already sounds great alone. Many speakers don't pass this test.
By the way, the Cantatas have the same drivers and driver array as the Alethas. They only differ in enclosure geometry and the placement of the midrange drivers. On the Alethas the midrange drivers are recessed while on the Cantatas only the tweeter is recessed. The Alethas and Cantatas sound similar, but I had a clear and distinct preference for the Cantatas. Unfortunately, I did not hear them side by side, but I did hear each side by side with a pair of SCIIIs, which I know very well. I thought the Cantata had better imaging and depth than the Alethas.
For what it is worth, last night while listening I kept thinking to myself how sublime these speakers are, and I was completely sober. With these speakers you listen to the performance, not the recording. Strengths: Very, very smooth response from top to bottom; truly beautiful midrange; fantastic imaging and detail with air without harshness or unnatural exaggeration; sublime soundstage depth and width. Weaknesses: They were harder to place than my previous SCIIIs. They need to be 10ft or more on axis from the listening position and they need to be far apart. The resulting soundstage really highlights strange mic placements or mixes. Since they are best on axis, the sweetspot is narrow, although I also enjoy them very much off-axis. Similar Products Used: Upgraded from a Dunlavy SCIII. Auditioned lots of speakers: Dunlavy Aletha, IV/A, Proac, Infinity, PSB, Martin-Logan, Wilson/Watt, NHT, Tannoy
|