|
Review NaN of Summary: Surprisingly, this combo has not been reviewed here. I bought them as the final change in upgrading my system, started 12 months ago thinking I was just going to get a more powerful amp than my little Naim, looked at Carver on mail orderstarting reading this site, started auditioning, and now with a McCormack TLC/1, DNA.5 combo driving my new Legacy Sig 3s, I have the whole shebang upgraded (and the bank balance seriously downgraded). I was looking to replace my 5 year old Rotel 945ax, found no satisfaction with Marantz 63SE or even the Rega Planet and realised I probably needed to step up to a serious player. Got a great deal on these as an ex-demo clearance from a Parasound dealer and could not resist. I use the standard coaxial link (TARA Decade). Nice simple design (though my wife could not figure out how to set the DAC once when I unplugged in a storm and upon power-up, it defaulted to AES/EBU - she claims she pushed every switch and could not get it to work before giving up). As long as it's plugged in, the DAC will keep a memory of the normal setting. Loading is a bit fiddly with the clamp and the remote control is the worst I have ever experienced - limited functionality and extremely narrow range of operation. But these are fairly minor quibbles soon forgotten when the music starts.
I am not a huge believer in expensive digital and with so much change imminent in format and sampling rates etc. I was tempted to sit on my Rotel for another year or so to see what happened. However, opportunity arose and the money spent on this has never been regretted (but then do we ever regret anything once we've bought it and it is not a disaster?). Compared to others, it is super smooth, emminently musical, and seems to just give back more of the music. It's not simply a matter of detail to my ears, this player seems to control everything and sound more solid than other players. Not as warm and bassy sounding as the Rega, but it makes the Rotel sound a bit rough in comparison. I have not tried the DAC with my old Rotel so I can't say which component is more important, but the combination of the belt driven transport and the dac is very satisfying to my ears.
Physically, the transport weighs a ton, it makes other players seem like toys. The dust cover needs to be kept closed as the laser tray is a dust trap. Player automatically stops when the door is slid back. Read a review in one mag that said you could hear the transport whirring during quiet passages - I've not experienced that, mine is silent. Aesthetically it's a bit plain - all black, slightly industrial/utilitarian style, no real effort (or money) put into making it look expensive, and that's fine by me if the rest of the package is good, and in this case it is.
I subscribe to the garbage in- garbage out school of reproduction, but I conclude from my last year of listening that the CD component made the smallest incremental change in sound. I got the most drastic difference switching to Sig 3 speakers from my Kef 103/2s, and then from the amp change. The front end was the icing on the cake and leads me to view all claims for super improvements in cd players with caution. I suppose if I feel motivated I could set up all combos of amp/speakers/front end since I kept my old system and moved it to the bedroom, but right now, things sound so nice I can' t be bothered changing anything. This is the best system I ever owned and I have never heard better in anyone's house. So, in short, I recommend this combo, and now that Audio Advisor are selling the DAC at 25% off list, I think they may be available at the right price. I seriously doubt I would have paid anything close to the list price of $3500 for them or any CD player.
Final review - great sound, but poor remote and very pricey at list, so 4 stars. If you can get the pair for under 2k, then a great 5 star set-up.
|