|
Review 2 of 2 Summary: The path to audio nirvana continues. The most recent equipment upgrade tomy system is a Proceed DAP digital to analog converter. With this purchase I also needed to buy a digital coax cable. The cables I have tried so far are Audioquest Video 2 (2 meter, $109), Audiodyne datalink (.5 meter, $60) and Transparent Premium Digital Link (1 meter, $250).
Associated equipment: Magnavox CDB-473 CD player/transport Proceed DAP Nordost Black Knight interconnect to pre-amp db Systems dbr-15 pre-amp Audioquest Ruby interconnect to amps db Systems db-6-ma 140 watt Mono amps Heavy Monster Cable speaker wire (30' run) Vandersteen 2Ce speakers on Vandersteen sand filled stands
Test Recordings Reference Recordings RR-38CD Howard Dunn w/ Dallas Wind Symphony, Fiesta. Tracks 1 and 5 (first two minutes of each) Loreena McKennitt, The Visit, track 5, Greensleeves Jackson Brown, Running on Empty, track 9, The Load-Out Chet Atkins & Mark Knopfler, Neck and Neck, track 8, Tahiatian Skies Rick Wakeman, The Six Wives of Henry the Eight, track 4, Jane Seymour Mercury 434 346-2, Byron Janis piano, Moussorgsky, Pictures at an Exhibition
Test Period Jan. 20-25, 1998
Observations: All of these cables are handsome and well constructed. The Transparent is the coolest looking of the bunch with its silvery braided outer jacket. The Audiodyne is well constructed and is actually terminated with gold plated 1/4 turn BNC connectors and has gold plated RCA adapters. The Audioquest is also a very handsome cable with gold plated RCA adapters. All three cables are directional in that the shielding is grounded at one end only. For these tests, the grounded end was attached to the digital output of the CD transport.
In most respects the Audioquest and Audiodyne cables exhibit similar sonic characteristics. The Audiodyne seems to have a slight edge in low bass definition whereas the Audioquests revealed a bit more of the woody texture of Bassoon. Castanets sounded different on the two, but I could not say which sounded better or more realistic. Both sounded very good.
I returned the Audioquest cable and my dealer (Audio Advice, Raleigh, NC) loaned me a Transparent Premium Digital Link cable to try. I therefore could not put it head to head against the Transparent cable. The differences between the Transparent and Audiodyne are more pronounced (of course, so is the price difference). The Transparent cable clearly opens up the soundstage and is unforgiving in its revelation of recording defects, hiss, breathing, foot movement, etc. Switching back to the Audiodyne consistently closed in the soundstage (though it still had nice depth and width). As for bass definition, power and weight, to my ears it is a draw. All three cables yielded nice focus and placement of instruments and vocals.
The most significant thing I heard, though, is a hardness that the Transparent cable seems to add to (or reveal in?) the music. Repeatedly, while I liked the broadened soundstage, the glare bothered me. Overall, it made the sound seem a bit thin. This was especially noticeable on the solo piano and on the Jackson Brown and Loreena McKennitt tracks. The overall effect was that I heard more detail but less of the emotion in the music.
Certainly, my system has its weak spots ... the speaker cables and possibly the CD transport being the most obvious. In the past I have auditioned Transparent Music Link and Music Link Ultra interconnect cables against MIT 2, Monster Reference A and Audioquest Ruby. On that occasion I also found the Transparent cables to leave me with a hard, almost harsh sound. In that case, I preferred the sound of the MIT interconnects.
Based on what I have heard so far, I am going to keep the Audiodyne cable. It is very well made and the company, which has one of the best internet sites I have seen in the audio realm (www.audiodyne.com), was a pleasure to deal with. Is it the best cable you can buy? Of course not, but then again, neither is my system. It is reasonably priced and can clearly stand up to some of the better cables in the business. It is revealing, fast and full range and allows the music ... and its emotional component to shine through. It must be remembered that when comparing the sound of components, and especially cables, subtlety is the name of the game. Even the differences which I have singled out such as soundstage width and hardness are pretty slight and take careful listening to quantify.
As everyone will tell you, let your own ears be your guide.
|