at80at

Overall Rating
 2 of 5

Value Rating
 2 of 5

Used product for
Less than 1 month

Visitors rate this review
3.00 of 5, 1.00 votes

Price Paid:  $120.00

Summary:
I consider myself a bit of an audiophile and really appreciate a good sounding system or component (in this case headphones). I wanted them for my various .MP3 players (I tried them out on the new Creative ZEN, Apple iPOD, my Nokia XpressMusic 5310, laptop, and other devices). Frankly I was disappointed. While the sensitivity and clarity was high, the sound-stage was muddled and uneven and the bass very weak. I did not enjoy the music through these headphones. I would only consider them for video / TV viewing on my laptop as its strength is in its clarity / sensitivity so voice / mid-range is good.

Strengths:
Clarity
Sensitivity
Mid-range

Weaknesses:
Lack proper sound-stage and timbre
Lack bass

Similar Products Used:
Sony
Philips

skibummsp

Overall Rating
 4 of 5

Value Rating
 4 of 5

Used product for
Less than 1 month

Visitors rate this review
4.75 of 5, 4.00 votes

Price Paid:  $180.00 from Best Buy

Summary:
Looking for something better than the Sony, over-the-ear headphones I was using with my 5th generation 30-gig iPod, I went and tried these out. One of my co-workers had a pair of the Shure E2c headphones that he brought into work and let me try out. Once I got them to fit properly, I really did like how they sounded. I thus decided I wanted to go a step up and get the E3c. The models beyond the E3c were getting beyond what I wanted to pay for a pair of headphones.

First and foremost, the fit on these things is extremely important. I was a bit skeptical as I could never seem to find a pair of decent in-ear headphones that I could get to fit properly, found uncomfortable, or would stay in my ear. It did take me a bit of experimentation until I could get the E3c's to fit properly (be sure to watch the little "how to fit/use" video on the www.shure.com website). I ended up using the medium sized grey "soft-flex" sleeves and seem to fit very comfortably and provided the best sound isolation and audio response for me. If you do not get a proper fit with these things, the bass will be very lacking and the highs will be "mushed" out. Thus, it is highly recommended to buy these things from a reputable dealer with a good return policy. For example, if you buy them directly from Shure, they have a 30-day money back gurantee. This is important for those that may not be able to get these to fit properly or find them uncomfortable for proper use.

Once I got these to fit properly, I was quite impressed with how good these sound with the music that I primarily listen to, which is symphonic power and progressive metal. For example, after listening to the Vox Tempus In the Eye of Time album (one of my reference albums, due to the extemely clean, very dynamic, and well-done recording quality), I found the vocals to be very clean and natural sounding, especially on the track "Love, Lies, and Treason". I can easily pick out each, individual instrument, with each instrument having its own space. The drums came out sounding very crisp and clean, with a good bit of punch. Even the kick-drums came out sounding good and punchy, but not boomy at all. I found the bass overall to be clean and accurate, but not boomy and "over-done" at all. This may put off those that want or expecting the big "boom-boom-boom" sound, but I personally find that to be annoying and unnatural, especially since I don't listen to rap, hip-hop or many of the other "bass-heavy" genres anyway.

Overall, if somebody is looking for a good, sleek, light-weight, in-ear "ear-bud" type headphone, these are definitly worth checking out, although a bit on the pricy side at $180 to $200 (depending on where you getting them).

Strengths:
Sleek, small, and light-weight.
Available in both white and black (I have a black iPod, so the black ones worked out perfectly in that sense)
Good clean, detailed mids and highs.
Clean, accurate bass.
Comes with a very nice carrying case.
Comes with several differnt types and sizes of "sleeves" to help with finding a good fit.

Weaknesses:
Takes a bit of experimentation to find/get proper fit
Can be unforfortable for some folks
May be difficult for some folks to get a proper fit.
Somewhat pricey, but still pretty reasonable for what you are getting here.

Similar Products Used:
Cheap $30 pair of Sony over-the-ear "clip-on" headphones
Another cheap $20 pair of Sony "over-the-ear" headphones that I use at work
Tried a pair of the Shure E2c's (borrowed from a friend)
The crappy pair of "ear-buds" that came with the iPod.
A somewhat better pair that came with the Creative Lab's MuVo Slim MP3 player (player I use while working out at the gym).
My father's Bose "quiet comfort" headphones.

Price Paid:  $81.00 from Amazon.co.uk

Summary:
Literally these arrived just this morning and I am listening as I type. They are awesome! I could not have believed music could sound so good.

For the purpose of this review, I will divide up my comments into strengths and weaknesses. In strengths I will look at ISOLATION, SOUND QUALITY, OVERALL QUALITY, COMFORT and ACCESSORIES.

For the weaknesses (if I find any!) will be outlined as best I can.

Please bear in mind that I am by no means an audiophile or muscian. I enjoy music and have more tracks on my iPod than moast people. The purpose of this review is to describe and explain my interpretation of these 'phones with non audio speak because I can not claim to actually know any such language. I am simply a consumer and I wanted to enjoy a better listening experience. Therefore this review is not by any means an expert analysis of the earphones but is my experience as an "average joe".

Strengths:
ISOLATION:

is great, I find the small flex and small plastic slieves are very good. The foam ones are also very good but I'll use them in public because I love the bright yellow look that makes them stand out and look different. Recently I have been getting so frustrated listening to my music in public, simply because I couldnt hear it with those "default" Apple earphones. You will really appreciate the difference when you walk out on the street and hear NOTHING but your beloved music instead of the sound of traffic and voices and then your music.

SOUND QUALITY:

is also very good. I listen to a variety of music ranging from Rock, Alternative, Classic, Metal, RnB, Electronica, Dance and Pop. Before purchasing these 'phones I relied on the reviews of others to make my mind up. I had been briefly put off them when I read several reviews that put them down on bass. To me they are just fine. I have turned the EQ on my iPod OFF for the first time ever. All I can say is WOW! Bass is very clear, true and punchy. It is there and although it isnt 'thumpy' it is fine for the type of music I listen to most. To be honest I appreciate better overall sound (which is what these 'phones do) rather than all the bass in the world and no quality.

I was torn between the Shure E3 and Etymotic ER-6i. Although I hadn't used either before, they both were given similar reviews. For both these 'phones bass was always a negative in many of the reviews I had read. So I was satisfied to accept that unless I wanted to spend serious amounts on earphones then I was always going to get mediocre bass. Although having recieved these Shure E3 I have no compllaints with bass (see above). In the end I went for the Shure E3 mainly because I read that the cable is of better qulity but also because I found them on Amazon.co.uk for the same price as the Etymotic Er-6i!

OVERALL QUALITY:

On that note of the cable, it is VERY good. Unlike many other earphones that have thin fiddly cables that look like they would snap if a sudden jerk, the cable on the Shure E3 looks like it could hold back a rhino! That is not a bad thing. It is thick enough so it doesn't tangle into knots but thin enough that it is comfortable and flexible.

The 'phones themselves are very good build quality. They seem very strong and I am satisfied that these will survive the everyday rough and tumble of student life.

You will not be disappointed with the quality of these 'phones. You can tell they have been well made for professional sound engineers, musicians and consumers alike.

COMFORT:

These 'phones are very comfortable. They make the Apple ones feel like they are a cactus rather than something that is supposed to be comfortable in your ears.! I am very pleased with the different sized slieves that came with these 'phones. The flex and plastic ones are very comfortable. I read other reviews that insisted the plastic ones were the most uncomfortable. My opinion is that they are the best overall. The foam ones are the best for isolation and the most comfortable. But they look like they will need replaced often with regular use. So I place the plastic ones first simply because they will save me money. I am considering purchasing the triple flange slieves because I have read they are very comfortable with almost as good isolation as the 'foamies'. By the way, isolation is VERY good with all these slieves (provided you get a good seal) so when I say isolation is better with one slieve than the other, it is a small fraction of a difference.

ACCESSORIES:

I am very pleased with all the accessories in particular the storage case. It is of very good quaity (like everything else!) I am conviced you can fit all the slieves and wax removal tool in this case easily. This is handy for travelling and offers great protection especially when you have spent so much.

Conclusion

In conclusion I would reccommend these 'phones to anyone who wants to enjoy their music in a new and unique way. Yes they are more expensive than what most people would consider spending on earphones but if you appreciate music you will understand. Also if you shop around you can find them at really good prices. I got them for £81.00 off Amazon.co.uk.

Previous to buying these earphones I had become quite bored of my music because I had heard most of it so many times- I listen to music for about 4 hours a day! Now I am listening to music in a totally new light. Instead of listening to tracks I have heard hundreds of times, I now listen to them as if for the first time. What I mean is the tracks sound totally different with these earphones and I am picking out sections that I have never heard beore!

You will appreciate music so much more with these 'phones and so I give them 5/5!

As I have said already my views are subjective as they are just that - my opinions. Earphones are very personal devices and so I hope this review helps outline what I think about these 'phones.

Weaknesses:
I cannot find any weaknesses worth noting. There are no signs of any likely weaknesses at this time but if I do find any I will update this review. I am quite sure that if I was an audiphile or muscian I could pick out weaknesses but as I am not such I think these 'phones are a massive improvement in the "default" Apple ones. In fact they would be a big improvement over any "default" or cheaper earphones.

Price Paid:  $100.00 from Sam Goody's

Summary:
Most people that would be interested in these buds are people who listen to portable audio devices. I use these headphones with an iPod. It's true they are quite a step-up from the buds you normally get with an mp3 player or disc player and they do make what you listen too sound good if not better. I have read what most reviewers have written about how thin the sound is from these Shures and at first I thought the same thing. I also hear comments about breaking the headphones in to finally hear good bass and I'm telling you it's not necessary if...

...you put the headphones in the correct way. This is described on the package and as weird as it sounds and looks, it works! The buds are supposed to be inverted and inserted into the ear canal with the cable looped over the ear. I was wearing these incorrectly at first, just placing them in my ear canal and the sound was horrible. Practically no bass and thin sounding! Made the freebie iPod Chiclets sound like heaven. I was shocked and was ready to return the Shures when I decided to give them another try. I noticed the suggested placement and tried it and BAM! the bass was good to go, the mids were right there and the highs were nice, not harsh @ all!

I listened to music all day with my Shures with one caveat...my ears started to hurt after prolonged use. Not my eardrums from the pounding but my inner ear where the bud was resting. That is the one thing I can legitimately complain about. You will notice the ache after using them for a long period. The bud not only rests in the ear canal but uses the inner ear to lodge in place. The isolation is great! You will hear stuff you never heard in your music before but you give up comfort after awhile when your ear starts to feel slightly sore from the bud being lodged in it. I do recommend this headset for all types of music if you want great sound isolation without the gimmick of noise cancellation. Great for the air traveler, not necessarily the best for the jogger or runner where they tend to fall out of the ear or the gym if you perspire alot around the ears.

All in all, very good sounding headphones. I'm glad I took the time to look at them further before taking them back. Good construction (cables not too thin or too long) and nice pouch with bud attachments made this a pretty decent purchase.

Strengths:
Very good sounding. VG bass and mids. Good construction.

Weaknesses:
Inverted placement takes time to get used to. Takes a few moments to put buds in your ears just right. Ears feel sore after prolonged use.

Similar Products Used:
Sony Fontopia buds.

Yen

Overall Rating
 2 of 5

Value Rating
 2 of 5

Used product for
3 Months to 1 year

Visitors rate this review
4.25 of 5, 4.00 votes

Price Paid:  $179.00

Summary:
I'm disappointed with the sound quality of these ear-phones for the money spent. The bass is very weak (no matter how I've tried to wear them). I've had them now a year and use them just because I spent the money but must say that I've only wasted my time tolerating the poor fidelity (thinking they would break-in). The upper treble seems to fall off very quickly too. I'm all about enjoying music, so even though these come with a nice case and multiple choices of ear plugs, I recommend saving your money for something else. Something else to consider regarding this particular type of headphone, these form an air-tight seal in your ear and is difficult to get use to. You'll feel like you need to equalize the pressure on the eardrum. You'll also notice noisy distractions from yourself (like chewing gum) due to the non-open-air design. This sounds kinda stupid until you use them and realize how much of a distraction it can actually be.

Strengths:
Well made, solid and durable. Nice case and has optional choice of ear plugs.

Weaknesses:
The sound quality is just not very good. Unacceptably weak bass and upper treble.