|
Review 1 of 17
Price Paid:
$450.00
from Second Hand Summary: Description: floorstanding speakers, 4 drivers including 1 x 250mm side-mounted woofer, 95dB SPL sensitivity, 8 -ohms nominal, 200Wrms, bi-wirable, 94x25x43cm.
I bought these floor-standers to use with my Sonic Impact T-Amp, a 2 x 10W class-D amp. The speakers have high sensitivity (95dB SPL), a good nominal impedance (8ohms), and the reviews on AudioReview.com said they sounded great, so I bought a pair online for $NZ450 (~US$250)
Keenly anticipating instant karma I hooked them up to my T-Amp and DVD-player. The sound was gross. There was very little bass from the side-firing 10" woofer, regardless of where I positioned these rear-vented speakers. What was the point of such a large cabinet???
I tried out some CDs: Bjork "Post", Radiohead "OK Computer". Vocals, and the mid-range were very forward. The Kronos quartet lacked "stringiness". The treble rolled off too early, so cymbals lacked bite and definition. Furthermore, the difference in the amount of treble between on-axis response, and *just*-off-axis was large. There was no way I could use these for home theatre, with the poor off-axis treble the sound-staging was crap!
The T-amp sounded much more defined driving my old AR M3s with 90dB SPL sens. There was off-axis "air" and sound-staging for my audience co-members.
I also swapped out the cheapo DVD player for my vintage Philips CD850, with no improvement in sound.
Watching a movie, I got so sick of the sound from the 310HO's that I swapped them out for my Mirage M790's floor-standers. These are merely 87dB SPL & 6ohms, with a tweeter and a single 8" woofer, but even THEY got the low bass a-growling from my beloved T-Amp. I mean, what the f***??!
I also tried the 310HOs in my main system, with a 2 x 100Wrms high-current amp (Rotel Michi RHB05). The sound was pretty much the same. However, I did find one positive point: that with a big amp the 310HOs REALLY CRANK UP LOUD - cleanly too, with no fuss. But the bass STILL lacked impact.
What I learnt:
(1) What lies beneath... Beware if a speaker manufacturer fuses the grille to the cabinet to prevent you from directly viewing the drivers; it probably is better for you if you didn't know what was hiding there. Wouldn't YOU be suspicious if Toyota sold a car where you weren't allowed to see under the hood?
(2) I must differentiate between reviews given by those who use Kenwood receivers, and those who use other stuff ;o)
Associated equipment:
Transonic DVD player (cheap!)
Philips CD850 (CDM-4 mechanism)
Audio Alchemy DDE v2.0 D/A converter
DIY relay-driven 12-step attenuator & input selector
Rotel "Michi" RHB-05 power amp (100w/160w)
Sonic Impact T-Amp powered by sealed lead acid battery
Mirage M790 floorstanders
Acoustic Research M3
Strengths: Great power handling & sensivity. With 100 quality watts they will go VERY LOUD cleanly, without compression. Bloody impressive, but bass still lacks impact. Weaknesses: Turns music into mush. No floor-spikes. Treble has awful off-axis response and also rolls off too early. Different timbres can be indistinct, mid-range is over-emphasied. Goes VERY LOUD but sound is bad! What should be rendered as smooth bass-lines, are not portrayed as such. No off-axis soundstaging. Similar Products Used: Mirage M790 floorstanders
Acoustic Research Holograhic Imaging M3 stand-mounts
B&W P5 floorstanders
Mission 731iLe stand-mounts
|